No hidden fees. No forced sign-up. Just accurate, ready-to-use stubs in minutes.
If you have been comparing your options, this page is built for exactly that. We put together an honest pay stub generator comparison so you can see, line by line, how PayStubVault stacks up against the tools you have probably already looked at, before you hand over your card details.
Pricing and features last verified: . We recheck this page regularly so you are never comparing against outdated numbers.
Order summary
1 pay stub, all 50 states
First stub is $0.00 — this card shows what a paid stub costs. No line items appear after you start.
Price per Stub
$1.99
States Covered
All 50
Account Required?
No
Hidden Add-On Fees
None
A single, flat price per paycheck stub, no surprise charges buried at checkout, no "premium template" upsell after you have already entered your income.
You have probably already got a tab open for at least one of these. Rather than send you back to read six separate review pages, here is the short version — one honest comparison per tool, with a clear edge called out instead of a vague sales pitch.
SecurePayStubs is a familiar name, but several independent reviewers flag add-on charges that only show up at checkout. PayStubVault keeps its $1.99 rate flat, with every tax calculation included from the start.
As an alternative to ThePayStubs option, PayStubVault focuses on a speedier, easier process in which you enter your personal information and then, after a preview of the stub, save the PDF. You don't need to create an account for you to start.
Positioned as a 123PayStubs alternative, PayStubVault is built with freelancers and independent contractors in mind rather than being an addition to a bigger payroll system.
As a SecurePayStubs alternative to pay for itself, PayStubVault's simple $1.99 cost is simple to explain and to budget for, with no different tiers to be decoded.
FormPros bundles pay stub creation alongside dozens of unrelated form types. PayStubVault does one thing: accurate income documentation, and does it with less clutter.
Both tools are commonly compared as budget picks. If you're hunting for the cheapest pay stub generator, PayStubVault's transparent flat rate and free first stub make the actual cost easier to verify upfront.
Every pay stub site claims to be the best one. Instead of asking you to take our word for it, we would rather show you, against whichever tool you are actually deciding between. Pick a name below and we will pull it up next to us so you can judge for yourself.
Pick Who You are Weighing Us Against
Tap a name to add it to the table below. Tap again to remove it.
| Feature | PayStubVault | Competitor |
|---|---|---|
| Price per stub | $1.99 | — |
| 50-state tax accuracy | — | |
| Free preview before paying | — | |
| Account required | — | |
| Hidden or add-on fees | None reported | — |
| W-2 and 1099 support | — | |
| Reported trust concerns | None on record | — |
Data compiled from public pricing pages, user forums, and published pay stub generator reviews as of . Some competitor claims are self-reported by the vendor and have not been independently verified; treat those rows as directional, not definitive.
Six reasons we hear most often from people moving over from the tools on this page.
The price you see when you start is the price you pay. No surprise line items appear once you have already entered your income.
See exactly what your employee earnings statement will look like before you spend a dollar.
Freelance income, contract work, small-business payroll — the builder adapts to non-traditional pay patterns, not just a standard W-2 job.
Federal and state tax withholdings are calculated automatically, so your income verification document holds up to scrutiny.
Generate your stub and download it. We don't require an account just to get a payroll document you'll use once.
Whether you need to document employee wages or self-employment income proof, the templates cover both W-2 and 1099 forms.
(Screenshot of the builder preview, before payment, coming soon.)
A lot of the “best pay stub generator” review blogs you will find are actually run by competing pay stub tools; ranking themselves first is not exactly neutral. Across independent sources and user forums, one complaint shows up again and again: hidden add-on fees that appear only after you have entered your details. That is part of why we built PayStubVault around a flat, visible rate, and why we would encourage you to read reviews with that pattern in mind, regardless of which tool you choose.
Direct answers to the questions people ask while comparing pay stub generators.
No tier where the good features unlock. No add-on at checkout. The number on the left is the number on your card.
PayStubVault
$1.99
flat per stub, every stub, first one free
Same five things, elsewhere
Source: each vendor’s public pricing page, as of .